Will challenges

The grounds on which a will can be set aside, who can bring a challenge, and what the court expects to see.

A challenge, from review to hearing

  1. ReviewThe wills and the available evidence are reviewed.
  2. ObjectionA notice of objection is filed, or the application is answered.
  3. DirectionsThe court sets the issues, the parties, and the steps.
  4. RecordsMedical and legal records are obtained by court order.
  5. MediationThe parties meet with a mediator.
  6. HearingA judge decides the issues that remain.

What a challenge is

A will that was properly signed and witnessed is presumed to be valid. A person with a financial interest in the estate can ask the court to set it aside. The court does not order a full inquiry on suspicion alone. The person objecting must first point to some evidence that the will may be invalid.

The grounds

  • Lack of capacityThe person making the will did not understand what they owned, who might expect to inherit, or what the will did.
  • Undue influenceSomeone pressured the person so strongly that the will reflects that other person's wishes. Persuasion is not enough. The pressure must amount to coercion.
  • Lack of knowledge and approvalThe person did not know or approve of what the will said when it was signed.
  • Improper signingThe will was not signed and witnessed as Ontario law requires. For a death in 2022 or later, a court can still accept a document that sets out the person's final wishes.
  • Suspicious circumstancesFacts around the making of the will, such as a beneficiary arranging it, require the person relying on the will to prove that it is valid.
  • Forgery or fraudThe signature is not genuine, or the person was deceived about what was being signed.

If a will is in dispute

What we need from you, and why

  • A copy of the will, and any earlier wills.If a will is set aside, the earlier will usually governs. The value of a challenge depends on what that earlier will says.
  • Your relationship to the person who died.Only a person with a financial interest in the estate can bring a challenge.
  • The date of death, and the date you learned of the will.Time limits apply. Many claims must be started within two years, and some within six months.
  • What you know about the person's health when the will was made.Capacity is assessed as of the dates of the instructions and the signing. Medical records and the drafting lawyer's notes are the main evidence, and a court order is usually needed to obtain them.
  • Whether probate has been applied for or granted.An objection filed before the certificate is issued stops the court from issuing it until the objection is dealt with.

What we do on your file

  • Review the will, the earlier wills, and the facts, and tell you whether there is enough evidence to proceed.
  • File a notice of objection, or respond to one.
  • Ask the court for directions, and for orders to produce the medical records and the lawyer's file.
  • Represent you at mediation. Mediation is required in contested estate matters started in Windsor, and a court can order it elsewhere.
  • Negotiate a settlement where one is available, and proceed to a hearing where one is not.

Claims that are not a will challenge

  • Support for a dependant.A spouse, child, or other dependant who was not adequately provided for can ask the court for support from the estate. The application is generally due within six months after probate is granted.
  • A married spouse's election.A married spouse can choose a division of family property in place of the will. The election must be filed within six months after the death.
  • Costs.The unsuccessful side in an estate dispute is usually ordered to pay part of the other side's costs. The estate does not automatically pay for everyone.

Limitation periods and court deadlines can apply. We may not be able to take on urgent matters.

This page is general information about Ontario law. It is not legal advice for your situation.

Ready when you are

Let's get your matter moving.

We'll confirm fit and outline your next steps.