Estate trustee and beneficiary disputes

What a beneficiary is entitled to, what an estate trustee must answer for, and how the court resolves a dispute between them.

A dispute, from request to resolution

  1. RequestInformation and an accounting are requested in writing.
  2. AccountsThe estate trustee delivers the accounts.
  3. ObjectionsObjections are filed, and the estate trustee responds.
  4. MediationThe parties try to settle, with or without a mediator.
  5. HearingA judge decides what remains in dispute.

Two sides of one relationship

An estate trustee controls the estate, and the beneficiaries are entitled to what is left after the debts and taxes are paid. Most disputes begin in that gap. A beneficiary is not told what is happening, or an estate trustee is accused of delay, of favouring one person, or of taking too much. The law gives each side specific rights, and the court supervises both.

If you are a beneficiary

What we need from you, and why

  • A copy of the will, and the certificate of appointment if one was issued.They show what you are entitled to and who is responsible.
  • What you have been told, and when.A beneficiary is entitled to information and to a full accounting. Many estates take a year or more, so a period of silence is not always misconduct.
  • What you have received so far.An interim payment affects what remains to be claimed.
  • Your specific concern.Delay, missing assets, a sale below value, and excessive compensation are each handled differently.

If you are an estate trustee

What we need from you, and why

  • Your records.Bank statements, receipts, and a list of every amount received and paid. An estate trustee who cannot account may have to repay the estate.
  • Your correspondence with the beneficiaries.It shows what they were told and what they agreed to.
  • The compensation you have taken or intend to claim.Compensation taken before the beneficiaries or the court approve it can be ordered repaid.
  • Any transaction between you and the estate.An estate trustee who buys estate property or benefits personally must show that the beneficiaries agreed or that the court approved.

What we do on your file

  • Request a full accounting, or prepare one in the form the court requires.
  • Apply to the court for a passing of accounts, or respond to objections to the accounts.
  • Ask the court for directions when the will is unclear or the estate trustees cannot agree.
  • Apply to remove an estate trustee, or defend the application. A court removes an estate trustee only when the administration of the estate is at risk.
  • Recover estate property held by someone else, including property transferred before death.
  • Negotiate a resolution and record it in a signed release.

Things to know

  • Joint accounts and gifts before death.An asset placed in joint names with an adult child may still belong to the estate. The court asks what the parent intended.
  • Compensation.The usual guideline is 2.5 per cent of the money received and 2.5 per cent of the money paid out. The court adjusts it for the size of the estate and the work involved.
  • Costs.The unsuccessful side is usually ordered to pay part of the other side's costs, and an estate trustee can be ordered to pay personally.

Limitation periods and court deadlines can apply. We may not be able to take on urgent matters.

This page is general information about Ontario law. It is not legal advice for your situation.

Ready when you are

Let's get your matter moving.

We'll confirm fit and outline your next steps.